2020 Road Map to a VBAC in the Chicago Area
You had a c-section with your previous pregnancy and now you’re pregnant again. Will you try for a vaginal birth after cesarean (VBAC) this time around, or will you plan a repeat c-section? This article points you to some third-party resources that will help you consider which way to go, and then walks you through the process of finding the best VBAC providers.
- VBAC or repeat Cesarean — resources to help you decide
- Choosing a VBAC-friendly hospital and practitioner
- Best Chicago-area hospitals for VBAC
- Options for midwife-attended VBAC [being updated – coming soon]
- VBAC in a midwife-led birth center
- Options if you’ve had two prior C-sections (VBA+2C) [being updated – coming soon]
- A complete list of Chicago-area hospitals where VBAC rates are above average..
[Note that several Chicago-area home birth providers may offer the option of a home birth after cesarean, but only if your most recent birth was a successful VBAC. This article focuses on options for women who have not had a vaginal birth since their last cesarean, so we don’t address the option of VBAC at home.]
The old adage “once a cesarean, always a cesarean” has been debunked.
The American College of Obstetricians and Gynecologists (ACOG) current practice bulletin relating to VBAC takes the position that women with one or two previous c-sections are candidates for a trial of labor after cesarean (TOLAC) and should be counseled about and offered a TOLAC. (See “Summary of Recommendations and Conclusions” section in full text of Practice Bulletin.) ACOG also recognizes that “the ultimate decision to undergo TOLAC or a repeat cesarean delivery should be made by the patient in consultation with her obstetrician or obstetric care provider. The potential risks and benefits of both TOLAC and elective repeat cesarean delivery should be discussed.”
The American College of Nurse Midwives (ACNM) similarly encourages a trial of labor after c-section (TOLAC): “Women who are candidates for labor after cesarean should be encouraged to consider VBAC.
So VBAC is an option every woman should at least look into.
Here are some resources to help you weigh trial of labor vs. planned cesarean:
- ACOG FAQs: Vaginal Birth After Cesarean Delivery – Deciding on a Trial of Labor After Cesarean Delivery – FAQs from the American College of Obstetricians and Gynecologists
- Childbirth Connection – offers a helpful overview of VBAC, including “VBAC Basics”, “Planning Ahead”, “Research and Evidence”, and “VBAC Resources”
- International Cesarean Awareness Network (ICAN) – a leading national organization dedicated to preventing unnecessary cesareans, supporting cesarean recovery and promoting vaginal birth after cesarean (VBAC)
- Lamaze International infographic – a one-page summary of facts about VBAC
- VBAC.com – a source for evidence-based information, resources, continuing education and support for VBAC
- VBAC Facts – offers a comprehensive paid online course for women and their partners that will walk you through the research and other considerations to help you decide whether you’re interested in VBAC
Choosing a provider for trial of labor after cesarean (“TOLAC”)
If you decide to try for a vaginal birth this time around, your first priority should be to find a supportive provider. You’re not just looking for someone who says “yes”, you’re looking for someone who enthusiastically supports a trial of labor after c-section.
This is the key piece of advice offered by Erica Fleischer, who is a Co-Leader of the Chicago Chapter of the International Cesarean Awareness Network, Inc. (ICAN) — a nonprofit organization whose mission is “to improve maternal-child health by reducing preventable cesareans through education, supporting cesarean recovery, and advocating for vaginal birth after cesarean (VBAC).”
As Fleischer explains, “You’ll hear from a lot of providers that, ‘Sure, you can have a VBAC.’ But then if you don’t go into labor spontaneously before 39 or 40 weeks, they want to do a repeat c-section. Or if you develop a medical condition that means you need to deliver right away, they refuse to induce you, so they’re basically requiring you to have a c-section. We always tell people that the most important thing is to have a provider is truly supportive.” That means providers who actively promote VBAC.
Dr. Richard K. Silver is the Chairman of Obstetrics and Gynecology and Chief Academic Officer at NorthShore University HealthSystem. He practices at NorthShore’s Evanston Hospital, which is where Erica Fleischer had her VBAC and which has one of the very best VBAC rates in the Chicago area. Dr. Silver attributes the hospital’s excellent outcomes in part to the fact that it’s a Level III hospital, which means that the doctors and midwives there see some of the rare but serious complications that can arise when a woman has multiple cesareans.
As Dr. Silver explains it, “Repeat cesarean is more risky for the mother. For instance, we inherit patients from other hospital systems when their placenta grows through the uterine wall and threatens their life. We handle up to 20 cases a year. These are really challenging cases, involving transfusions, multiple surgeries, urological issues. This is one of the risks of repeat cesareans and one of the long term consequences of not offering vaginal trial of labor appropriately.”
So what does it mean to offer trial of labor appropriately? Dr. Silver’s answer is that it starts with good counseling. “You have to be non-coercive, but you also have to overcome the understandable barrier. Someone’s had a less than ideal experience with their prior labor and it ended with c-section. If it were me, I’d raise my hand and say, ‘This time, let’s skip the labor and just repeat the cesarean.’ You can absolutely understand why they’d make that choice. So you have to address that with factual data, with good information, including the effect that a second cesarean section may have on the pregnancies after this one. Women need the data.”
Saint Anthony Hospital is another top performing hospital for VBAC in the Chicago area. Saint Anthony has a unique model: all pregnant and laboring women are cared for in the first instance by Saint Anthony’s midwives, backed up by a team of obstetricians. That means that the culture at Saint Anthony strongly reflects the midwifery model of care — a culture of patience, confidence in the natural process of birth, respect for the broad range of normal, and an emphasis on communication and shared decision-making.
According to Dr. Michele Bucciero, Saint Anthony Hospital’s Clinical Director in Obstetrics and Gynecology, that culture is key to the hospital’s excellent VBAC outcomes. “You have to explain to patients why you’re not necessarily intervening right away and why you’re letting them do things on their own. And I think you have to be patient. You can’t be anxious, running to the back for surgery if they don’t make progress every two hours. You have to give them the time.”
Michelle Korzek, CNM, is the Directory of Midwifery Services at Saint Anthony Hospital. She attributes the hospital’s culture of patience in part to the unique perspective that midwives bring. “As midwives, we’re not going to look at someone who’s had a previous c-section as being ‘abnormal’ per se. We always look at birth as a normal life process. That gives us confidence to leave the process alone more of the time.”
It’s clear that the midwives and OBs at Saint Anthony are totally aligned on this. As Dr. Brucciero says, “It’s how midwives train and how they look at birth, which is so drastically different than how obstetricians train and look at birth. If I were interested in a trial of labor after cesarean, I would definitely want a midwife taking care of me.”
The question of training is clearly important. Dr. Silver has been in practice for more than 30 years and he has seen drastic changes in approaches to VBAC over that time. “When I was in training, we offered pretty much everybody a trial of labor and the success rate was around 80%. For women with non-recurring indications [meaning that the reason for their previous c-section is not likely to recur this time around], 8 or 9 out of ten would delivery vaginally. And even those with the lowest odds of success, maybe someone who got stuck at seven centimeters or who pushed for four hours and still couldn’t deliver her baby, even those women have a 50/50 shot at delivering vaginally.”
Dr. Silver believes that providers can have skewed perceptions of the risks and benefits of a trial of labor. “Sometimes providers forget that if they allow trial of labor often enough, they’re going to be avoiding a lot of surgeries.”
Of course, it’s not providers but mothers who actually undertake the trial of labor. That raises another important component of good counseling, according to Dr. Bucciero. “Women need to go into it with realistic expectations. For most, it’s not going be a rapid birth. Most likely it’s going to take a while, you’re going to be uncomfortable. It might be a little anxiety provoking, and at the end of the day you may need another section. I think that’s just something people have to understand. So you need to be patient and realistic. And what that requires is confidence. It’s the provider’s job to give you that confidence.”
Dr. Silver agrees that confidence is critical. “When choosing a provider, I would ask, ‘what is the culture of your labor and delivery unit? Are your nurses and other folks supportive of this or do they get anxious when they have a patient with a scarred uterus?’” The anxiety of people around you can undermine your confidence and derail your labor.
Because it’s so important to find a supportive provider, don’t limit yourself to nearby hospitals. An hour or even an hour and a half drive might be inconvenient for prenatal visits and unpleasant when you’re in labor, but ultimately could be worth it.
As Dr. Silver points out, “People get anxious about being far from the hospital, but I think that’s a little overrated, especially with a VBAC. A lot of moms had a protracted first labor so they’re not likely to have a rapid labor this time around.” Dr. Silver has cared for vaginal trial of labor patients who live as much as an hour and a half away. That means you can look beyond the hospitals closest to you to find providers you really trust. In the list of top options for VBAC below, you’re likely to find a hospital well within a safe distance almost no matter where you live in the Chicago area.
Other factors to consider when choosing your provider
The most important thing is to find a provider who is supportive. But there are other considerations as well.
One is monitoring technology. Mothers trying for a vaginal birth after cesarean are required to have continuous electronic fetal monitoring, where a belt around their belly transmits fetal heart tones to a receiver. In some hospitals, the monitor significantly limits the mother’s ability to move around. But some hospitals offer the option of monitoring by telemetry, which transmits the fetal heart tones wirelessly. That allows the laboring woman to walk around instead of being tethered to the monitor. As Erica Fleischer puts it, “All Chicago area hospitals will require you to be monitored the whole time for a TOLAC [trial of labor after cesarean], but that doesn’t have to mean you’re stuck on your bed.” Being able to move around and try different positions can help you labor effectively, and an effective labor is less likely to end with a cesarean.
Another question to ask is whether there is an anesthesia team in the hospital at all times. This is important so that if a cesarean birth becomes necessary, it can be performed without delay.
And Fleischer has a few more recommendations for women who want a VBAC. “First, hire a doula. The evidence shows that they reduce the rate of c-sections, and that kind of support is particularly valuable for VBAC. Second, if your c-section was for failure to progress or failure to descend, consider body work like physical therapy, chiropractic or the Spinning Babies technique. There are plenty of women who address physical issues that made their first labor difficult and then have no issue with their next birth. And third, work through any emotional trauma you may carry from your first labor. ICAN offers support for that, including through a closed Facebook group.”
Not every mother who qualifies for and chooses a trial of labor will have a vaginal birth, although success rates tend to be very high, often around 80 – 90% or more. But for many woman, the decision to try for a VBAC has benefits even if another cesarean becomes necessary. Dr. Bucciero puts it like this: “ I think at the end of the day, even if people aren’t successful, I feel like they’re okay getting another c-section, knowing they put in their best effort. There is some kind of mental shift and bonding that happens just by going through the labor process, that a lot of people that walk in and get a c-section don’t necessarily experience. I feel like people that go through labor and really give it their all often end up more satisfied with their choice, even if they don’t end up having a natural delivery.”
Summing it up
Although the evidence supports trial of labor for most women who’ve had cesarean births, not all providers are wholeheartedly comfortable with VBAC. If you’re considering a vaginal birth this time around, don’t stop at a discussion with your current provider.
Instead, plan to get opinions from several doctors and/or midwives who support and have attended lots of successful VBACs. You’ll get a more balanced feel for the risks and benefits of a trial of labor by hearing multiple points of view, and you’re also more likely to find someone you truly connect with. A trusting relationship is especially important for a trial of labor after c-section since you need to feel confident that you and your provider have the same goals.
The best way to find VBAC-supportive providers is to start with hospitals and midwife-led birth centers that have high VBAC rates. (See our list below). Remember that not all hospitals and not all individual practitioners have the same criteria for trial of labor after cesarean. Just because you don’t qualify in one setting does not mean that you don’t qualify anywhere.
You don’t need to limit yourself to the hospitals closest to you. Many providers will agree to care for you even if you are traveling a distance to get to them. Given the importance of finding a supportive provider, cast a wide net if you need to.
When you’re interviewing providers at your setting of choice, here are some questions to ask:
- Will you allow me to go past my due date if that’s my informed decision?
- Are you willing to induce or augment my labor if that becomes medically necessary?
- Will I have fewer options in labor because I’ve had a previous c-section?
- What are the advantages and disadvantages of a trial of labor in my case?
- What are the advantages and disadvantages of planning a repeat cesarean in my case?
- How confident are you that I can successfully have a VBAC?
- Do you offer telemetric monitoring?
- Do you have anesthesia teams on-site 24/7?
Best options for trial of labor after cesarean in the Chicago area
If you’re planning a VBAC, here are answers to some of the questions you may have, including:
- What are the best hospitals for VBAC in the Chicago area?
- Where can I have a midwife-attended VBAC?
- Where can I have a VBAC in a birth center?
- Where can I have a VBAC after two cesareans (VBA2+C)?
- What hospitals have above-average VBAC rates?
⇒ TIP: You can use the BirthGuide search tools to find good VBAC providers. Go to the provider search page on BirthGuideChicago.com and use the “High VBAC Rate” filter in the left-hand column to find the hospitals with the highest VBAC rates:
Or use the drop down in the “Sort by” box to sort search results by VBAC rate, highest to lowest:
Best Hospitals for VBAC in Chicago
Based on most recent Illinois Department of Public Health statistics for VBAC rates and volumes (covering the period 04/01/2018 to 03/31/2019), the top five hospitals for VBAC in the Chicago area are:
- Saint Anthony Hospital (Chicago) – 39.6%
- Northshore Univ HS Evanston Hospital (Evanston) – 36.3%
- University of Chicago Medicine (Chicago) – 32.7%
- West Suburban Medical Center (Oak Park) – 31.8%
- Amita Health Saints Mary and Elizabeth Medical Center Chicago (Chicago) – 31.6%
These are the hospitals with the highest VBAC rates that also have high VBAC volumes (more than 50 successful VBACs per year).
There are a handful of additional hospitals that have excellent VBAC rates — comparable to or even higher than the top five — but whose low volumes make those rates less meaningful.
Here is a complete list of the Chicago-area hospitals with the best VBAC statistics, including those with smaller volumes.
- NorthShore University Evanston Hospital: More than 175 babies were born by VBAC at NorthShore University Evanston Hospital in the reporting year, and the hospital’s VBAC rate (36.3) is the second highest among hospitals that also had high volumes. Both midwives and doctors support trial of labor after cesarean. With a VBAC rate that is among the very highest for Chicago-area hospitals, and with the highest volume of VBACs among hospitals in this category, Evanston Hospital is one of the top two choices for VBAC in the Chicago area.
- AMITA Health Saints Mary & Elizabeth Medical Center: At Saints Mary & Elizabeth Medical Center, 55 mothers had successful VBACs in the most recent reporting year, representing over 30% of all mothers having their babies at the hospital after a prior cesarean birth.
- University of Chicago Medicine: The doctors and midwives at the Family Birth Center at the University of Chicago attended over 125 successful VBACs in the most recent reporting year, with a VBAC rate of 32.7% (up by nearly 4% compared to the prior year). With the third highest rate among hospitals that supported at least 50 VBACs, and with the second largest number of VBACs in absolute numbers, University of Chicago Medicine is a “top three” choice for VBAC in the Chicago area.
- Advocate Trinity Hospital: On the far South Side is Advocate Trinity Hospital. With a smaller volume of births overall, Advocate Trinity performs fewer VBACs (37 in 2018-2019) than some of the other hospitals on this list. But its excellent VBAC rate of 31.9% (up nearly 2% over the prior year) demonstrates a real commitment to VBAC.
- Roseland Hospital has a newly revamped labor and delivery service and their performance supporting VBAC is impressive. In their first year of reported VBAC statistics, Roseland had the single highest VBAC rate in the Chicago area by a substantial margin: it’s rate of almost 60% is half again as high as the next highest hospital, Saint Anthony. However, like Holy Cross Hospital (below), Roseland has a small volume of VBACs – only 15 in the reporting year, which is substantially below the 50-birth threshold for high volume of VBACs used in this survey. With those small numbers, rates can be a little misleading, since one VBAC can impact the rate disproportionately. That is why Roseland Hospital is not included in the top-five list this year. But without question, Roseland Hospital deserves kudos for its extraordinary support for women choosing a trial of labor after cesarean.
- Another South Side option you might consider is Holy Cross Hospital . At 34.6%, its VBAC rate is one of the highest in the area. Note that this is a very small L&D service and their overall birth volume is even lower than Roseland’s: in actual numbers, Holy Cross only supported 9 VBACs in the 2018-2019 reporting year.
- Saint Anthony Hospital: Among Chicago-area hospitals that supported at least 50 VBACs in 2018-19, the highest VBAC rate was reported by Saint Anthony Hospital on Chicago’s Southwest Side. Sixty-one mothers, representing almost 40% of mothers who had prior c-sections, successfully delivered vaginally in 2017-2018. This is up more than 7% over Saint Anthony’s already excellent rate from the prior reporting year. Saint Anthony’s has a unique model of care: all women are in the care of midwives in the first instance, supported as needed by back-up obstetricians. This is equally true for women choosing a trial of labor after c-section. With the highest VBAC rate among hospitals that supported at least 50 VBACs in the most recent reporting year, Saint Anthony’s is the #1 choice for VBAC in our area.
- West Suburban Medical Center: West Suburban Medical Center has a traditional labor and delivery unit where both doctors and midwives practice, and also has an in-hospital midwife-led Alternative Birthing Center, where all the rooms have birthing tubs and water birth is supported. With a VBAC rate of 31.8% and a good volume of VBACs (63 in the most recent reporting period), West Suburban offers an excellent option for families interested in VBAC.
Options for midwife-attended VBAC
All five of the top-rated hospitals offer midwife-attended VBAC:
- Saint Anthony Hospital (Chicago)
- Northshore Univ HS Evanston Hospital (Evanston)
- University of Chicago Medicine (Chicago)
- West Suburban Medical Center (Oak Park)
- Amita Health Saints Mary and Elizabeth Medical Center Chicago (Chicago)
This is not surprising. In general, whether a hospital has a midwifery-service correlates strongly with its VBAC rates. Specifically, of hospitals with above-average VBAC rates, 62% have midwives. By contrast, of hospitals with below-average VBAC rates, only 12.5% have midwives. Looked at another way, 72% of hospitals that have midwife services have above-average VBAC rates, while only 28% of hospitals with midwife services have below-average VBAC rates.
Other options for midwife-attended VBAC at hospitals with above-average VBAC rates (but not rates “among the highest”) are:
- Mercy Hospital (Chicago)
- University of Illinois Medical Center (Chicago)
- Norwegian-American Hospital (Chicago)
- Swedish Covenant Hospital (Chicago)
- Northwestern Medicine Prentice Women’s Hospital (Chicago)
- Elmhurst Memorial Hospital (Elmhurst)
- Advocate Illinois Masonic Medical Center (Chicago)
- AMITA Health Adventist Medical Center (Glen Oaks).
Options if you’ve had two prior c-sections (VBA2+C)
[Being updated] The American College of Obstetricians and Gynecologists takes the position that VBAC can be a safe and appropriate choice for some women who have had two prior cesarean births. Not all providers offer the option of VBAC to women who have had more than one c-section, but several do — including a number of the hospitals with the highest VBAC rates. If you’ve had two cesarean deliveries before this pregnancy, you may still have the option of a vaginal birth this time around, depending on the reasons for your past c-sections and other factors. The following hospitals are good places to start if this is something you’d like to pursue. Again, different providers will have different criteria for a trial of labor after two c-sections: just because one provider says no doesn’t necessarily mean they all will. [Coming soon.]
Option for VBAC in a midwife-led birth center
There are two midwife-led birth centers in the Chicago area: The Birth Center at PCC and the Alternative Birthing Center (or “ABC”) at West Suburban Hospital. The Birth Center at PCC is a freestanding birth center and Illinois regulations do not allow it to take VBAC patients. But the ABC at West Suburban Hospital is an in-hospital birth center and is equipped to handle VBACs. (Note that West Suburban also has a standard labor and delivery service where midwives also practice.) As a midwife-led birth center, the West Sub ABC follows the midwifery model of care, avoiding intervention whenever possible and offering hands-on support from providers who are experts in natural childbirth. Telemetry monitoring is available and the midwives are skilled at using positioning to help your labor along.
Complete list of hospitals whose VBAC rates are above average for the Chicago area
|Hospital/ Birth Center||City||# of VBACs in 2018-19||VBAC rate (2018-19)||Compared to other Chicago-area hospitals, this rate is . . .|
|*Roseland Community Hospital||Chicago||15||57.7%||among the highest|
|Saint Anthony Hospital||Chicago (South/West)||61||39.6%||among the highest|
|Northshore University HS Evanston Hospital||Evanston||183||36.3%||among the highest|
|*Holy Cross Hospital||Chicago (South)||9||34.6%||among the highest|
|University of Chicago Medicine||Chicago (South)||126||32.7%||among the highest|
|Advocate Trinity Hospital||Chicago (South)||37||31.9%||among the highest|
|West Suburban Medical Center||Oak Park||63||31.8%||among the highest|
|Amita Health Saints Mary and Elizabeth Medical Center||Chicago (Central)||55||31.6%||among the highest|
|Mercy Hospital & Medical Center||Chicago (Central)||55||27.4%||medium high|
|University of Illinois Medical Center||Chicago (Central)||101||25.3%||medium high|
|Advocate Good Shepherd Hospital||Barrington||44||22.9%||medium high|
|*Norwegian-American Hospital||Chicago (Central)||10||22.7%||medium high|
|*St Bernard Hospital & Health Care Center||Chicago (South)||20||22.2%||medium high|
|Mount Sinai Hospital||Chicago (West)||92||22.2%||medium high|
|Swedish Covenant Hospital||Chicago (North)||76||21.8%||medium high|
|CLOSED Metrosouth Medical Center||Blue Island||42||21.5%||medium high|
|Northwestern Medicine Prentice Women’s Hospital||Chicago (Central)||314||21.3%||medium high|
|Elmhurst Memorial Hospital||Elmhurst||59||20.8%||medium high|
|Advocate Illinois Masonic Medical Center (North)||Chicago||51||20.4%||medium high|
|Northshore Univ HS Highland Park Hospital||Highland Park||40||19.4%||medium high|
|*AMITA Health Adventist Medical Center Glen Oaks||Glendale Heights||12||19.4%||medium high|
*The hospitals with an asterisk perform 20 or fewer VBACs a year.
About the VBAC rates reported on BirthGuide
Providers are listed on BirthGuide as having a risk-adjusted VBAC rate that is “among the highest” if their VBAC rate is one standard deviation or more above the average rate for all hospitals listed on BirthGuide. (BirthGuide lists all maternity hospitals in Cook, Dupage and Lake counties that were included in the Illinois Department of Public Health’s “Illinois Health Report Card” as of 2/14/2019.) On the mobile version of the site, these providers’ VBAC rates are listed as “high”.
The VBAC rates used in this calculation come from the Illinois Department of Public Health (IDPH), which reports the VBAC rates for all Illinois hospitals. The IDPH VBAC rates reflect the number of women who have had at least one prior c-section in the past and who then have a vaginal birth at that hospital in the reporting year, divided by the number of all women who gave birth at that hospital in that year who have had at least one prior c-section. So the VBAC rate takes into account both the women who try for a VBAC and the women with a history of c-section who schedule a repeat cesarean with this pregnancy. The VBAC rates reported by IDPH are risk-adjusted.
Some providers also self-report their VBAC success rate. The VBAC success rate is the percentage of all women who choose a trial of labor who ultimately have a vaginal birth. That rate will be much higher than the overall VBAC rate because it considers only the population of women who qualify for and elect to try for VBAC, without taking into account women who are scheduled for a repeat c-section.
The highest overall VBAC rates will reflect both that a high percentage of women are offered a trial of labor and that skilled support helps a high percentage of those to succeed.
The photos in this article document a successful VBAC and are used with the permission of Amanda E Photography in Peoria Illinois.